Proof Before Punishment, Reform Before Ruin: A Two-Track Model for Forensic Reliability and Rehabilitative Justice in Pakistan

Authors

  • Minhas Johar LL.B. (Hons.), Quaid -e-Azam Law Collage, Lahore, Pakistan.
  • Samreen Pervaiz LL.M. Scholar, University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan.

Keywords:

Criminal Justice System; Diversion and Probation; Due Process; Forensic Evidence; Juvenile Justice; Pakistan; Rehabilitation and Reintegration.

Abstract

The criminal justice system in Pakistan needs to determine guilt in a dependable manner and choose lawful, non-discriminatory measures to help ensure public safety. This article proposes a combined system to achieve these goals. Track I focuses on examining forensic, medical, testimonial, circumstantial, and digital evidence, with a challenging application in serious criminal trials. Track II diverts, provides probation, and reintegrates suitable cases in a legal manner. They are both subject to the same constitutional safeguards and criminal standard of proof. The analysis is based on the provisions of the Constitution, the Code of Criminal Procedure, the Order on Constitution of Criminal Procedure – Qanun-e-Shahadat vide 20/12/2010, Fair and Substantive Criminal Law, the Juvenile Justice System Act and the relevant Punjab probation regime. These are not, as above, considered to be representative of judgments, but demonstrate evidentiary difficulties. Comparative examples compare forensic regulation in England and Wales, youth justice planning in New Zealand, and evaluated treatment court practice in the United States. The article suggests examining evidence schedules, making explicit eligibility decisions, and creating accessible plans for rehabilitation of the district pilot, which is to be independently evaluated. Through local hypothetical applications, there are implications for age determination, disputed recordings, services unavailable, and remote accessibility. The common thread is a similar reasoning-in-decision process, one that is both evidence-driven and correctional, for reasons, as well as for accountability and review. Neither foreign programme descriptions nor administrative caseloads establish effectiveness in Pakistan. The model thus underscores the importance of implementing and evaluating the proposal whilst keeping victim safety and the inclusion of defence participation, and the difference between holding someone up on bail, diversion, conviction, and sentence. This has relevance for countries globally; however, it is very important in Pakistan, where organized crime and juvenile diversion are not given appropriate attention, and the trust and reliability of criminal evidence is not maintained.  

References

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (Pakistan). https://pakistancode.gov.pk/

Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973. https://pakistancode.gov.pk/

Electronic Transactions Ordinance, 2002 (Pakistan). https://pakistancode.gov.pk/

Finigan, M. W., Carey, S. M., & Cox, A. (2007). Impact of a mature drug court over 10 years of operation: Recidivism and costs (NCJ 219225). National Institute of Justice. https://nij.ojp.gov/library/publications/impact-mature-drug-court-over-10-years-operation-recidivism-and-costs-final

Forensic Science Regulator & Home Office. (2025). Forensic science activities: Statutory code of practice (Version 2). https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/forensic-science-activities-statutory-code-of-practice-version-2

Forensic Science Regulator Act 2021 (UK). https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2021/14/contents

Ghulam Sarwar Ghangro v. The State, Jail Petition No. 166/2022, 2025 SCP 442 (Supreme Court of Pakistan, October 21, 2025). https://pakistankanoon.com/supreme-court-law-review/2025-sclr-33/

Juvenile Justice System Act, 2018 (Pakistan). https://lpr.adb.org/sites/default/files/2024-07/pakistan-juvenile-justice-system-act-2018.pdf

Muhammad Akram v. The State, 2009 SCMR 230 (Supreme Court of Pakistan, 2009).

National Institute of Justice. (2008, May 11). Do drug courts work? Findings from drug court research. https://nij.ojp.gov/topics/articles/do-drug-courts-work-findings-drug-court-research

Oranga Tamariki—Ministry for Children. (n.d.). Youth justice family group conferences. https://www.orangatamariki.govt.nz/youth-justice/family-group-conferences/

Pakistan Penal Code, 1860 (Pakistan). https://pakistancode.gov.pk/

Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act, 2016 (Pakistan). https://pakistancode.gov.pk/

Probation of Offenders (Amendment) Act, 2025 (Punjab Act V of 2025). Gazette of the Punjab, 2685–2686.

Probation of Offenders Ordinance, 1960 (as applicable in Punjab). https://punjabcode.punjab.gov.pk/uploads/articles/52-probation-of-offenders-ordinance-1960-xlv-of-1960-doc-1-pdf.pdf

Punjab Probation and Parole Service Act, 2019 (Punjab, Pakistan).

Punjab Probation and Parole Service Rules, 2025 (Punjab, Pakistan).

Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984 (Pakistan). https://pakistancode.gov.pk/

Tariq Pervez v. The State, 1995 SCMR 1345 (Supreme Court of Pakistan, 1995).

Tariq, A., & Khan, M. M. A. (2022). Aimless sentencing through probation in Pakistan: Time to revisit statutory and administrative practices. Pakistan Vision, 23(1), 67.

United Nations General Assembly. (1990). United Nations standard minimum rules for non-custodial measures (the Tokyo Rules) (Resolution 45/110).

United Nations General Assembly. (2015). United Nations standard minimum rules for the treatment of prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules) (Resolution 70/175).

Zahir Zakir Jaffar v. The State, Criminal Petition Nos. 467, 441, 442, 468, 469 & 485/2023, 2025 SCP 220 (Supreme Court of Pakistan, May 20, 2025). https://pakistankanoon.com/supreme-court-law-review/2025-sclr-31/

Downloads

Published

2026-11-19

How to Cite

Minhas Johar, & Samreen Pervaiz. (2026). Proof Before Punishment, Reform Before Ruin: A Two-Track Model for Forensic Reliability and Rehabilitative Justice in Pakistan. Al-Kashaf, 6(01). Retrieved from https://alkashaf.pk/index.php/Journal/article/view/309